Stop by the Bakery for a slice or a whole cheesecake!
Store flavors vary daily - call ahead for a specific flavor.

Traditional Cheesecakes

$36
per cheesecake
9"
round
12 or 16
slices
Five
day notice
Mail
order available
Buy!
Coming Soon!

Traditional Flavors are usually available daily, but order 5 days in advance to guarantee your order.
Pre-cut into 12 slices, unless otherwise requested. Shipping is additional.
View Traditional Cheesecake Flavors Here.

Specialty Cheesecakes

$40
per cheesecake
9"
round
12 or 16
slices
Five
day notice
Mail
order available
Buy!
Coming Soon!

Specialty Cheesecakes are available with 5 day advance notice. Shipping is additional.
View Specialty Cheesecake Flavors Here.

Premium Flavors

$44
per cheesecake
9"
round
12 or 16
slices
Five
day notice
Mail
order available
Buy!
Coming Soon!

 

 


Premium Flavor Cheesecakes are available with 5 day advance notice. Shipping is additional.

 

Sampler, Seasonal & Make Your Own Cheesecake Flavor

$40
per cheesecake
9"
round
12
slices
Five
day notice
Mail
order available
Buy!
Coming Soon!




9" Sampler Cheesecake Notes:

For 9" Samplers Choose 4 or 6 Traditional Flavors (advance notice) or walk in and create one with up to 12 flavors in it! (12 slice only)

Samplers are a big hit for parties and presents!
 

Gluten Free / Vegan Cheesecakes

$46
per cheesecake
9"
round
12 or 16
slices
Five
day notice
Mail
order available
Buy!
Coming Soon!


7" Cheesecakes

Traditional Flavors

$25
per cheesecake
7"
round
8
slices
Five
day notice
Mail
order available
Buy!
Coming Soon!

Assorted flavors offered daily or call ahead 4-5 days in advance.

7" Sampler

$29
per cheesecake
7"
round
8
slices
Five
day notice
Incl:
Rasp, NY, Choc, Caramel
Buy!
Coming Soon!

Cupcake Minis

$2.75
per mini
48
minimuum order
24
per flavor
Five
day notice
2.25"
Size
Trad
Flavors Only

2.25" round. Cupcake Minis are in white liners but you may bring your own liners in.

Petite Minis

$2.50
per mini
48
minimum order
24
per flavor
Five
day notice
1.75"
Size
Trad
Flavors Only

1.75" round. There is no liner for Petite Minis.

Minimum order 48 mini cheesecakes per order. Baked in batches of 24 per flavor.
All traditional flavors.
* If ordering over 150 minis, specialty flavors may be available

3" Sweetheart Cake - $10.00

(min order: 4, 1 flavor per every 4).

1 Dozen Assorted Cupcake Mini Cheesecakes - $33.00

Random flavors, no substitutions, based on availability. Walk in or call to see what is available.
 

By The Slice (walk in basis only)

Assorted flavors daily - $4.00
Gluten Free / Vegan slices - $5.00

Muddy Paws Signature Cheesecakes

The Mud Paw Cheesecake

$40
per cheesecake
9"
round
12 or 16
slices
Five
day notice
Mail
order available
Buy!
Coming Soon!

Coffee Chocolate & Caramel Swirl layers topped with pecans, caramel, and chocolate paws, nestled on a chocolate pecan crust.
Or Try The Mud Puppy Cheesecake! All of the goodness listed above without the pecans.

The Mardi Gras (or Viking / Packer)

$40
per cheesecake
9"
round
12 or 16
slices
Five
day notice
Mail
order available
Buy!
Coming Soon!

Almond Amaretto Cheescake with green & purple swirls ..... A cheesecake fit for a celebration!

The Grand Paw Cheesecake Tart

$79
per cheesecake
12"
round
24
slices
Five
day notice
Pick
Up Only
Buy!
Coming Soon!

Our famous New York Cheesecake topped with glazed layers of kiwi, strawberries and blueberries!
It's our giant cheesecake that serves 24 people!


"We have recently updated our pricing. This is our first price change in 9 years! Our cost of ingredients and overhead has increased over this time period. We are still competitively priced however, while offering you the BEST CHEESECAKE IN THE UNIVERSE!"