Traditional Cheesecake Flavors

9" (Serves 12-16) $39

Baileys Irish Cream
Banana Cream
Black Forest
Blueberry Swirl
Cafe Au Lait
Caramel Pecan
Caramel Swirl
Cherries n’ Cream
Chocolate Chip
Chocolate Decadence
Chocolate Marble
Chocolate PB Chip
Chocolate Toffee
Double Chocolate Chip
Espresso Kahluà
Heath Bar
Honey Vanilla
Key Lime
Lemon Drop
Mint Chocolate Chip
Mocha Cappuccino
New York
Pecan Praline
Pumpkin Swirl
Raspberry Chocolate Chip
Raspberry Choc Truffle
Raspberry Swirl
Snicker Bar
Strawberry Swirl
Very Berry
White Chocolate

(Walk in slices available too, assorted flavors, $4)

Specialty Cheesecake Flavors

9" Serves 12-16 $43
(Not Available for Samplers)

Almond Amaretto Chocolate Chip
Andes Candies Mint Chocolate Chunk
Apple Crumb
Apricot White Chocolate
   (Coffee Liqueur, Amaretto & Irish Creme)
Bailey's Chocolate Swirl
Banana Mango
Banana Rum Dream
Banana Split
Banana Walnut
Bananas Foster
Banoffee (Banana Toffee)
Black Cherry Amaretto
Black N White
Black Raspberry Chambord
Blueberry Pistachio Cranberry
Bourbon Vanilla
Brownie Caramel
Brownie Cookie Dough
Butter Rum
Butterscotch Almond
Butterscotch Caramel
Caramel Cashew
Caramel Crunch
   (Caramel, Peanuts, Milk Chocolate Chip)
Caramel Flan
Caramel Hazelnut
Caramel Irish Cream
Caramel Coffee Liqueur
Caramel Macadamia Nut
Cardamom Pistachio
Chai Tea
Cheesecake made with Mars Bar & Chocolate Mint
Cheesecake Sundae
   (Banana, Strawberry, Chocolate layers)
Cherry Almond
Cherry Chocolate Brownie
Cherry Rum
Cherry Streusel
   (Chocolate Banana)
Chocolate Almond
Chocolate Amaretto
Chocolate Apricot
Chocolate Brownie Caramel
Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough
Chocolate Covered Strawberry
Chocolate Creme Brulee Swirl
Chocolate Frangelico (+$4)
Chocolate Grand Marnière (+$4)
Chocolate M & M
Chocolate Malt
Chocolate, Peanut Butter & Banana 
Chocolate Pecan Turtle
Cinderella (PB Cheesecake)
Chocolate Salted Caramel

Coconut Chocolate
Coconut Mango
Coffee Caramel
Coffee Chocolate Chip
Coffee Liqueur & Chocolate Mudslide
Coffee Praline
Cotton Candy
Cranberry Lemon
Cranberry Walnut
Cranberry White Chocolate
Crazy Carrot Cake
Creme Brûlée
Crystalized Ginger
   (Tye-dye cheesecake)
Double Chocolate Chip White Chocolate Chunk
Dulce de Leche
Elvis Cheesecake
   (Peanut Butter & Banana)
Espresso Hazelnut
Espresso Irish Cream
French Silk
Fuzzy Navel
Gentleman Jack
German Chocolate
Ginger Molasses
Ginger Spice
Gingerbread White Chocolate
Green Tea
Honey Lavender
Honey White Chocolate
   (Rum, Lime, Pineapple, Orange)
Irish Coffee
Key Lime Raspberry
Key Lime White Chocolate
Lemon Blueberry
Lemon Curd Swirl
Lemon Hazelnut
Lemon Lime
Lemon Marscapone (+$4)
Lemon Poppy Seed
Lemon Raspberry
Mai Tai (+$4)
Mandarin Orange
Mango Lime
Mango Pineapple
Maple Brown Sugar
Marbled Grasshopper
Mardi Gras

Milk Chocolate Almond
Mint Oreo
Mud Paw (The Classic!)
Mud Puppy (Classic minus Coffee)
   (Strawberry, New York, Chocolate)
Oatmeal Chocolate Chip
Oatmeal Stout
Orange Chocolate Swirl
Orange Dreamsickle
Orange White Chocolate Oreo Salted Peanut Butter
Peach Cobbler
Peaches n Cream
Peanut Butter & Jelly
Peanut Butter White Chocolate
Peanut Butter Caramel
Pina Colada
Pineapple Coconut Pineapple
Pink Lemonade
Pistachio Dream
Praline Chocolate Chip
Raspberry Walnut
Reese's Peanut Butter Cup Chunk
Rhubarb Crisp
Rocky Road
Root Beer Float
Rose Water Pistachio
Salted Caramel
Salted Nut Roll
Spotted Cow
   (Spots of Double Choc Chip in New York)
Strawberry Banana
Strawberry Daiquiri
Strawberry Lemonade Strawberry Margarita
Strawberry Pineapple
Strawberry Rhubarb
Sunshine Orange
Surly Coffee Bender Cheesecake         Take 5     Tequila Lime                                         Tiramisu (+$4)
Triple Berry Chocolate Chip
The Hawaiian: Banana, Pineapple, Coconut
Tunnel of Fudge
2 Gingers Whiskey Cheesecake
Vanilla Bean Cheesecake (+$4)
White Chocolate Chunk Macadamia Nut
White Chocolate Chunk Raspberry
White Chocolate Hazelnut
White Russian

Signature Cheesecakes

The Mud Paw Cheesecake $43 (12 or 16 slice)

Our signature cheesecake! Coffee Chocolate & Caramel Swirl layers topped with pecans, caramel and chocolate paws, nestled on a chocolate pecan crust. 

The Grand Paw Cheesecake Tart (9” $50, 12” $80)

Jaw dropping party cheesecake! Our famous New York cheesecake topped with layers of kiwi, strawberries, raspberries and blueberries. 

Sampler Cheesecakes

9" cut into 12 slices: 4-5 day notice or Stop in and Create One Any Day you Wish! ($43)

3 slices of 4 different flavors. Choose any 4 traditional flavors or walk-in & make a sampler from daily slices available at our bakery.

*Samplers are not available on specialty flavors, vegan or gluten free.

Seasonal Cheesecake Flavors

9" serving 12-16 (4-5 day advance notice. $43)

Apple Butter Swirl
Candied Sweet Potato with White Chocolate
Candy Cane (December favorite!)
Caramel Apple
Chocolate Eggnog

Gingerbread White Chocolate
Peanut Caramel Apple Pecan Pie
Peppermint Patty
Pumpkin Pumpkin Baileys Pumpkin Salted Caramel
Pumpkin Chocolate
Pumpkin Chai


Pumpkin Pecan
Pumpkin Spice
Pumpkin Toffee
Pumpkin White Chocolate
Southern Sweet Potato Sweet Potato White Chocolate

Make Your Own Flavor

(9" cut 12 or 16 slices $43)

Choose up to three of your favorite ingredients to create the cheesecake of your dreams! Sports teams colors are also available! 

Cheesecake Alternatives

(Available in 9" only. Also, we feature at least one gluten free and/or vegan cheesecake by the slice daily as well.)
Did you know we are the only certified cheesecake bakery of vegan cheesecakes and gluten free cheesecakes in the world?! Yep! But this comes at a huge cost and very low profits. Also, we go to great lengths to be cautious with allergens and dedicate separate days for baking. Please give us extra time for these orders and know we are making them for your joy.

We make: Vegan, Gluten Free, Vegan & Gluten Free, Sugar Free and Lactose Free Cheesecake. No samplers available on these cheesecakes. They are 9" in size serving 12-16. 4-5 Days Notice Needed. Or call us to see what is in stock (we try to carry 1-2 flavors daily in gluten free and in vegan by slice & whole). ** Contact Muddy Paws Cheesecake for Gluten Free-Vegan and Sugar Free Cheesecake flavors.

Gluten Free Flavors ($49)

Raspberry Swirl Caramel Swirl
Key Lime
Chocolate Decadence
Chocolate Raspberry Truffle
New York Chocolate Marble
Pumpkin or Pumpkin Swirl Strawberry Swirl                                              

Vegan Flavors ($52)

*Lactose Free version available as well

Raspberry Swirl
Peanut Butter
Chocolate Decadence
Chocolate Raspberry Truffle
New York
Pumpkin or Pumpkin Swirl
Apple Cinnamon     OREO              Strawberry Oreo        Strawberry Swirl

7" Cheesecakes

Order any of our traditional flavors in a 7" size cheesecake. Traditional flavors are $27 and we need 4 days notice. We do have some 7" flavors stocked daily too.) They are cut into 8 slices.

*These make for great centerpieces for events too! We can cut them into 10 slices for $4 extra

Mini Cheesecakes and Sheet Cheesecakes

Mini cheesecakes are great for meetings, special events and weddings!

Cupcake Cheesecakes are a full size 2.25” cupcake size. Petite Minis are 1.75” in size.

Cupcake minis: $2.75 each (Any traditional flavors)

Petite Minis: $2.50 each (Choice of: Chocolate, New York, Key Lime, Lemon, Raspberry, Pumpkin, Baileys, Almond)

You can order one flavor per every 24 minis. If you are needing a dozen vs 24, call us to find out which flavors we can do. (Mini Cheesecakes are time consuming and we bake each one to order, hence flavors are limited. But they are great for grab n go, are adorable and they taste just as incredible as our big cheesecakes!) We need 4 days notice. *Note: you may bring in your own colored liners for the cupcakes.

Sheet Cheesecakes

We offer sheet cheesecakes in any of our flavors, except sugar free or vegan. They serve 50-100 (depending on how big you want the squares). These come uncut but we can cut them for $6 extra. We need 4-5 days notice. Keep frozen or refrigerated until serving.


Traditional Flavors $65 Specialty Flavors $71 Gluten Free $80

 *NOTE: For small bites, we can also cut 9” cheesecakes into 36-50 squares (except for weddings) for $4 extra, with 4 days notice.

Fresh Fruit, Sauces & Toppings

$4-$6 each (8oz.) (We have some in stock but other toppings need advance notice)

Blueberries ($6)
Blueberry Topping Brownie Crumbles
Butterfinger Crumbles
Caramel Sauce Chocolate Chip Cookie Crumbles
Cherry Topping
Chocolate Syrup Graham Cracker Crust Crumbles Granola
Kiwi ($5)
Lemon slices

Lime Slices
Mangos ($5)
Reeses Crumbles
Raspberries ($6)
Raspberry Sauce
Strawberries ($6)
Strawberry Sauce
Triple Berry Sauce
Oreo Crumbles Heath Crumbles

Can of Whip Cream $6

Special Order Crusts

$6 Extra

Chocolate Brownie
Chocolate Chip Cookie
Pretzel Crust
Ginger Snap

BIRTHDAYS & WRITING ON CHEESECAKES: We can write with chocolate on any 9” cheesecake (except vegan) or sheet cheesecake. $4 extra.

Nut Crust
Oreo Crust
Sugar Cookie